Can you switch car insurance after an accident?

Why you can trust Insure.com

Quality Verified

At Insure.com, we are committed to providing the timely, accurate and expert information consumers need to make smart insurance decisions. All our content is written and reviewed by industry professionals and insurance experts. Our team carefully vets our rate data to ensure we only provide reliable and up-to-date insurance pricing. We follow the highest editorial standards. Our content is based solely on objective research and data gathering. We maintain strict editorial independence to ensure unbiased coverage of the insurance industry.

After an accident, your current premium stays the same until renewal — your insurer cannot raise your rate mid-policy in most states. A new insurer, however, will price in the accident immediately. That difference alone means switching too soon often costs more than staying put, even if a competitor’s headline rate looks lower.

For most drivers, the smarter move is to let the current policy run its term and use that time to compare quotes properly. Our data shows rates jump an average of 60% after one at-fault accident, so the stakes are high enough to be deliberate about it. Whether switching ultimately makes sense also depends on whether a claim is still open, what discounts would be lost by leaving, and how different insurers are likely to price a recent accident — because that varies more than most drivers expect.

Can you switch car insurance companies at any time?

Drivers can switch car insurance companies at any point during a policy term — not just at renewal. But timing matters more than most people realize. Our analysis of more than 5 million insurance quotes found that rates typically jump an average of 60% after one at-fault accident. A new insurer will apply that increase immediately, while your current insurer cannot raise your rate until renewal. For most drivers, that gap makes staying put the cheaper option in the short term — even if a competitor is offering a lower headline rate.

Where you live also plays a significant role in how much your premium rises after an accident. In Michigan, a driver paying $3,964 before an at-fault accident can expect to pay $7,831 after — nearly double. At the other end of the spectrum, Rhode Island drivers see a far more modest rise. The size of that increase is what makes the switching decision so consequential — and so worth getting right.

Before doing anything else, check your renewal date. If you have more than a few months left on your current term, use that time to gather quotes rather than act on them — that way you’re ready to move the moment renewal arrives without paying a new insurer’s post-accident rate a day sooner than you have to.

Can you switch insurers while a claim is still open?

Switching insurers during an open claim is permitted, but it means managing two separate companies at once until the claim is resolved. Your old insurer remains responsible for the open claim regardless of whether you’ve moved to a new provider. Switching doesn’t transfer the claim, change the coverage limits that apply, or affect how the settlement is calculated.

Until the claim is fully settled, you’ll be dealing with two insurance companies simultaneously — your old one for the claim and your new one for ongoing coverage. That adds administrative complexity and potential for confusion, particularly if the claim involves ongoing negotiations or litigation.

• Your old insurer handles the open claim. You cannot file the claim with your new insurer or change coverage limits retroactively to affect the current accident.
• Your new insurer covers you going forward. Any new incidents after the switch date are covered by the new policy.
• You cannot backdate coverage. Attempting to falsify accident dates to adjust coverage is insurance fraud, which can result in policy cancellation and legal consequences.

How much do rates increase after an accident by state?

Post-accident premium increases vary dramatically by state — from around 30% in Rhode Island to nearly 100% in Michigan. High population density, heavier traffic, elevated medical costs, and litigation-prone legal environments all push surcharges higher in certain states. Our data shows a Michigan driver paying $3,964 before an at-fault accident can expect to pay $7,831 after — almost double. Meanwhile, a Rhode Island driver sees their rate rise from $2,878 to $3,754 after the same type of incident.

What to read next

How much will my insurance go up after an accident?

What happens if someone who isn't on your insurance crashes your car?

What to do after a car accident that's not your fault

Are OEM or aftermarket parts used in your car insurance repair?

Does car insurance cover reckless driving?

"Diminished value" car insurance claims get the wrecking ball

Show more

Our agents make it hassle-free to get the right quote.

Call (844) 814-8854

Ethan Available Now

Jack Available Now

Robbie Available Now

Ellie Available Now

What to consider before switching insurers after an accident

Switching insurers after an accident can save money — but it can also cost more than staying put if the timing is wrong or valuable discounts are left on the table.

Four factors determine whether switching after an accident will actually save you money: where you are in your policy term, what discounts you’d be giving up, whether accident forgiveness is already in place, and whether cancellation fees apply.

Your current rate is locked until renewal

In most states, your insurer cannot raise your premium mid-policy. That means your current rate — even post-accident — is protected until your renewal date. A new insurer will see the accident immediately and price it in from day one. If you have several months left on your current term, staying put is often cheaper in the short term.

You may lose discounts you’ve built up

Loyalty discounts vary widely by insurer — Nationwide offers up to 21% for customers in their first year, while Allstate can save loyal customers up to 26%. State Farm’s discount grows to 18% after 10 years. Those figures can easily outweigh what a new insurer appears to offer on paper.

Here’s how discounts compare from top insurers:

Accident forgiveness may already protect you

If you have accident forgiveness on your current policy, using it may be the smartest financial decision available to you. This benefit prevents your first qualifying at-fault accident from triggering a rate increase — but it doesn’t transfer to a new insurer. If you switch, you lose it, and the new insurer will surcharge you for the accident. Check whether you have this coverage before you do anything else.

Cancellation fees may apply

Some insurers charge a cancellation fee for mid-policy termination. It’s usually modest, but worth checking before you commit to a switch. Your insurer may also owe you a prorated refund for any unused portion of your prepaid premium — ask about both before canceling.

When does it make sense to stay with your current insurer?

Staying put is often the right short-term move in the months immediately following an accident. These are the situations where it makes the most financial sense.

• You just started a new policy term. Your rate is locked until renewal. A new insurer will factor in the accident immediately, making your current policy likely the cheaper option for now.
• You have accident forgiveness. If this protection is in place and applies to your accident, using it and staying with your current insurer prevents the rate increase entirely — something no new insurer can offer you.
• You have a vanishing deductible or significant loyalty discount. These perks take years to accumulate and disappear the moment you leave. Factor their value into any comparison before switching.
• Your claim is still open. Coordinating between two insurers while a claim is active adds complexity and risk. Waiting until the claim is settled makes the transition cleaner.

When is switching insurers the smarter move?

Switching makes genuine financial sense in specific situations — and in some cases, staying is clearly the wrong call.

• You’re approaching renewal and your insurer is raising your rates. Renewal is the natural switching point. If your insurer is about to increase your premium, shop the market before signing on for another term.
• You received poor claims service. If your insurer handled the accident poorly — slow response, unfair settlement offer, poor communication — that’s a legitimate reason to leave regardless of timing.
• You’ve found a meaningfully lower rate elsewhere. If another insurer offers significantly cheaper coverage for the same protection, and the savings outweigh any discounts you’d lose, switching makes financial sense.
• You have no accident forgiveness or loyalty perks to lose. If you’re not sitting on accumulated benefits, the calculation is simpler — compare rates and go with the better deal.

How to switch car insurance after an accident

Switching insurers after an accident follows the same steps as any policy change — the main difference is making sure the timing is right and that nothing falls through the gaps.

• Determine how much coverage you need. Review your current coverage levels and decide whether they’re still appropriate. This is a good opportunity to assess whether your liability limits are high enough — the average collision claim costs $5,489, and bodily injury claims can reach far higher.
• Get quotes from at least three insurers. Rates vary significantly between carriers, especially for drivers with a recent accident. Compare the same coverage levels and deductibles across each quote so you’re making a fair comparison. Check insurer reviews and financial stability ratings alongside the price.
• Ask your current insurer to match the best rate. Before you commit to switching, give your current insurer the opportunity to retain you. They may offer a rate match or additional discount that makes staying worthwhile.
• Check for cancellation fees and potential refunds. Ask your current insurer whether a mid-policy cancellation carries any fees, and whether you’re owed a prorated refund for unused premium. Refunds are typically calculated to the date of cancellation.
• Buy the new policy before canceling the old one. Never let your coverage lapse — even for a single day. A coverage gap can result in fines, license suspension, and higher premiums with future insurers who view lapses as a risk signal.
• Cancel your old policy in writing and confirm it. Once your new coverage is active, cancel the old policy and get written confirmation. Remember that any open claims remain with the old insurer — switching doesn’t transfer them.

How to get cheaper car insurance after an accident

A post-accident rate increase is common but not fixed. These strategies can meaningfully reduce what you pay while the surcharge is in effect — and some work regardless of whether you switch.

• Stay with your current insurer until renewal. Your rate is locked mid-policy. A new insurer will price in the accident immediately, making your current policy likely the cheapest option until renewal.
• Shop around every six to twelve months. Insurers rate risk differently, and the gap between the most and least expensive option for the same driver can be hundreds of dollars. Getting quotes regularly is the most reliable way to avoid overpaying.
• Ask about all available discounts. Accident forgiveness, loyalty discounts, bundling, low mileage, and safe driver programs can all offset post-accident surcharges. Always ask your insurer — or a prospective insurer — to confirm you’re receiving every discount you qualify for.
• Raise your deductible. Increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 typically reduces your premium by around 11%. Only do this if your emergency fund can comfortably cover the higher deductible if you need to file a claim.
• Enroll in a usage-based program. Telematics programs that track driving behavior can earn discounts of 10 to 30% for safe drivers — without requiring any changes to your coverage.
• Complete a defensive driving course. Many insurers discount drivers who complete an approved course after an accident or ticket. It signals to the insurer that you’re actively working to become a lower-risk driver.
• Reconsider coverage on older vehicles. If your car has a low market value, dropping collision and comprehensive and carrying liability only may no longer make financial sense. Check your car’s current value before your next renewal.

What are the risks of switching car insurance after an accident?

Switching comes with real financial downsides that are easy to overlook when a lower premium is on offer. These are the most common ones.

• Loyalty discounts. Most insurers offer loyalty discounts that build over time — typically 3 to 4% per year. These disappear when you leave and take years to rebuild with a new insurer.
• Accident forgiveness. If you have this coverage and haven’t used it yet, switching means losing the protection before you can benefit from it. A new insurer will surcharge you for the accident instead.
• Vanishing deductible perks. Some insurers reduce your deductible each year you go claim-free. This benefit typically takes several years to accumulate and resets to zero when you switch.
• Bundling discounts. If you bundle auto and home with your current insurer, switching your auto policy may eliminate the multi-policy discount on both policies — not just the one you’re moving.

What our expert says

Carole WalkerExecutive director of the Rocky Mountain Insurance Information Association.

“Motor vehicle records are used by insurers to determine risk and those generally stay on your record for up to three years. So, before you switch insurance companies after a crash or claim of any kind, determine if that will actually save you any money and provide you the same level of coverage.”

Methodology

Insure.com’s rate quote analysis was based on 40-year-old male and female drivers driving a Honda Accord LX with 100/300/100 coverage and a $500 comprehensive and collision deductible. The analysis included more than 5 million quotes from 138 insurance companies.

Alisha Ambre

 

 . .

Alisha Ambre holds a Bachelor of Arts with honours in English Literature and Media Studies. She focuses on crafting clear, engaging content that makes complex information feel practical and approachable for everyday readers. When she’s not writing, she’s likely on the volleyball court or immersed in a good video game.