Comprehensive vs. collision car insurance

Comprehensive and collision coverage are the two types of car insurance coverage for physical damage to your vehicle. These two coverages protect your car, while liability coverage – mandatory in most states – protects you when you cause bodily injury or property damage to others.

Liability, collision, and comprehensive work together to protect you in the event of an accident. Comprehensive and collision are separate, optional coverages that allow you to make claims for damage or total loss of your vehicle, regardless of fault.

What is comprehensive car insurance?

Comprehensive insurance is a type of auto insurance coverage designed to help protect you and your vehicle against damage caused by an accident, vandalism, theft or any environmental hazards, such as hail, flood, etc. 

What does comprehensive insurance cover?

Comprehensive insurance generally covers your vehicle in these scenarios:

• Vandalism
• Theft
• Glass damage
• Damage from flying missiles (defined as any flying or propelled object, like an item falling off a vehicle) or falling objects (trees, boulders, etc.)
• Striking an animal
• Fire
• Floodwaters
• Damage due to natural events or severe weather (e.g. hail, wind, tornado, or hurricane)

If your vehicle is damaged due to one of these perils, after paying your deductible, your comprehensive coverage pays for the repairs or total loss up to the actual cash value of your car.

What is collision car insurance?

Collision insurance is a type of coverage offered to drivers that helps protect their vehicles from damage resulting from a collision with another vehicle or an object.

What does collision insurance cover?

Collision insurance covers your vehicle in these scenarios:

• Your car hits another vehicle
• Your car is hit by another vehicle
• When you hit a stationary object (e.g. tree, fence, house)
• Unintentional flipping, rolling or overturning of your vehicle

Collision covers your car from accident damages, regardless of fault. To make a claim, you will need to pay your deductible, and then your coverage will pay the remaining cost of repairs or the total loss of your vehicle.

What isn’t covered by comprehensive and collision insurance?

Comprehensive and collision insurance won’t cover the following situations:

• Wear and tear
• Mechanical failure (not related to an accident)
• Electrical failure
• Custom equipment that wasn’t listed and specifically covered on the policy or custom-equipment endorsement
• Additional damage caused by failing to take preventative measures
• Intentional actions
• Criminal actions (damages during your attempt to evade police)
• Confiscation or destruction of your vehicle by law enforcement
• Nuclear exposure or explosion
• Bio-chemical attack
• War
• Personal items damaged in or stolen out of your vehicle
• Damaged or stolen electronic equipment that wasn’t originally installed in your vehicle (Many aftermarket electronics require an additional endorsement.)

Having both comprehensive and collision on your vehicle protects you against many situations, but not everything. 

What is the minimum deductible for collision and comprehensive insurance?

Deductibles typically run from $250 to $1,000, though some insurers allow higher – up to $2,500. If your car is leased or financed, your contract normally requires your deductible to be set at a certain amount, typically $500 or lower.

A deductible is the out-of-pocket amount you pay before your car insurance coverage goes into effect to pay the remaining costs of repairs or actual cash value for a totaled vehicle. Deductibles are per incident, so you’ll owe a deductible each time you make a collision or comprehensive claim.

How much does comprehensive and collision coverage cost?

On average, drivers pay $255 a year for comprehensive insurance and $687 a year for collision coverage, based on a 2022 rate analysis by Insure.com.

What you pay for comp and collision depends on factors such as your driving record, the vehicle you’re insuring, and where you live. View the chart below to find the average cost of collision and comprehensive coverage in your state.

The table below shows collision and comprehensive insurance costs by state.

When you need comprehensive vs. collision insurance

Deciding between comprehensive and collision insurance comes down to what risks you want to be covered for. Comprehensive is helpful if you’re worried about things like theft, vandalism, natural disasters, or hitting an animal. Collision is key if you’re more concerned about damage from accidents—whether you hit another car or something like a fence or pole. If you lease or finance your car, lenders often require both. But if you own an older car outright, you might choose one or neither, depending on its value.

At the end of the day, comprehensive and collision insurance combined will provide you with the most robust coverage. 

Do I need comprehensive and collision insurance? 

You’re not required by law to have comprehensive or collision insurance. But having these coverages can save you from paying hefty repair or replacement costs out of pocket if something happens to your car. Whether it’s damage from an accident, theft, a falling tree branch, or even a run-in with a deer, comprehensive and collision coverage help protect your finances and give you peace of mind—especially if you wouldn’t be able to easily cover those expenses on your own.

If you don’t add comprehensive and collision, your vehicle will have no coverage under your car insurance policy. In an at-fault accident, collision coverage is the only way to make a car insurance claim for your vehicle’s damage or total loss. Without it, you’ll have to pay out of pocket yourself.

With the right coverage in place, if an uninsured driver hits your car, you can file a collision claim with your insurance company. They’ll cover the repair costs, minus your deductible, and then handle pursuing reimbursement from the at-fault driver. It saves you the hassle of trying to collect payment yourself—which could mean taking legal action and going to court to get a judgment.

How claims work for comprehensive vs. collision

Filing a claim is similar for both coverages. You’ll contact your insurer immediately if something happens—whether it’s a break-in (comprehensive) or a car accident (collision). They’ll ask for details and usually send an adjuster to check out the damage. You’ll pay your deductible, and they’ll cover the rest up to your policy limit. The biggest difference is what triggers the claim: comprehensive handles non-crash damage, while collision deals with accidents where your car collides with something.

When to drop comprehensive coverage

Consider dropping comprehensive coverage if the following situations apply:

• Your vehicle has a low resale value: Drop comprehensive coverage on your car if the market value of it is less than a few thousand dollars.

• Your vehicle is covered by another policy: If your family member insures your vehicle on their policy, you don’t need to pay for it again. Your car can only be covered on a family member’s policy if it is kept at their house.

When to drop collision coverage

If you own your car, there are only a few reasons to drop your collision coverage:

• If you’re currently not driving your car:  You don’t need collision car insurance if you never drive your car. However, comprehensive coverage can protect your vehicle against theft, vandalism, fire, and weather-related issues if it’s parked in a garage or storage. 

• Your car is insured on another policy: If your car is insured on another policy that includes collision coverage, you don’t need to have collision coverage on your policy. But your car can only be insured on a relative’s policy if it is parked overnight at their address.

• If your vehicle has minimal value: It’s a good idea to drop collision coverage if your vehicle is worth less than a few thousand dollars. This is especially true when you have a high deductible.

If you’ve kept your vehicle for a long time, past 10 years usually, your vehicle’s worth may have fallen so much that the cost of comprehensive and collision is no longer worth it.

How to save on collision and comprehensive car insurance

Adding collision and comprehensive coverage to your car insurance policy will make your premiums go up. But there are ways to save on collision and comprehensive insurance:

• Increase your deductible
• Complete a driver training or accident prevention course
• Improve your credit score
• Maintain a clean driving record 
• Take advantage of discounts 
• Enroll in a usage-based discount program
• Bundle your home and auto insurance policies
• Pay your annual car insurance premiums in full

Always ask your insurer if you’re receiving all the available discounts that should apply to your situation.

Comprehensive and collision insurance are two of the most important types of auto insurance coverage that every motorist should consider. After all, having this coverage can offer peace of mind during unfortunate events like a collision with another vehicle or when your car is stolen or vandalized. 

In addition, full coverage insurance is required by lenders if you lease or finance your vehicle. Be sure to research thoroughly and pick the right kind of policy for you.

Methodology

Insure.com commissioned Quadrant Information System to field rates for comprehensive and collision coverage with a $500 deductible from up to 123 company groups across the U.S. based on the profile of a 40-year-old driver with a clean driving record and good insurance score driving 2021 Honda Accord LX.